Skip to main content
  • About
  • Public Officials
  • Topics
  • Courses
  • Publications
  • Blogs
  • Resources
  • Giving
  • Knapp Library
  • MPA Degree
  • About
    As the largest
    university-based local
    government training,
    advisory, and research
    organization in the United
    States, the School of
    Government serves more
    than 12,000 public officials
    each year.
    • Mission and Values
    • News
    • Faculty and Staff
    • School of Government Foundation
    • Diversity and Inclusion
    • Visitor Information
    • Accessibility
    • Employment
    • SERVICE Mural
    • Our Impact
    • Browse by Role
      The School provides
      content and resources for a
      wide array of local
      government and judicial
      officials in North Carolina.
      Select your role to explore
      all related content.
      Local and State Government
      • Appointed Board Members
      • Attorneys
      • City and County Clerks
      • City and County Managers
      • Community and Economic Development Professionals
      • Elected Officials
      • Health and Human Services Professionals
      • HR Professionals
      • IT Professionals
      • Managers and Supervisors
      • Planning and Zoning Professionals
      • Tax and Finance Officials
      Courts and Judicial Administration
      • Appellate Court Judges
      • Clerks of Court
      • Criminal Defense Attorneys
      • District Court Judges
      • Guardians ad Litem
      • Indigent Defense
      • Jailers and Corrections Officers
      • Judicial Administrators
      • Juvenile Court
      • Law Enforcement Officers
      • Magistrates
      • Prosecutors
      • Superior Court Judges
    • Browse by Topic
      The School provides content
      and resources on a wide array
      of topics in local government
      and judicial administration in
      North Carolina.
      Select a topic to explore all
      related content.
      Local and State Government
      • State Government
      • Planning and Development Regulation
      • Community and Economic Development
      • Environment
      • General Structure and Authority
      • Health and Human Services
      • Human Resources
      • Information Technology
      • Intergovernmental Relations
      • Leadership and Management
      • Local Government Finance
      • Open Government
      • Other Local Government Functions and Services
      Courts and Judicial Administration
      • Civil Commitment and Guardianship
      • Civil Law and Procedure
      • Corrections
      • Criminal Law and Procedure
      • Evidence
      • Family Law
      • Indigent Defense
      • Judicial Administration and Authority
      • Juvenile Law
      • Motor Vehicle Law
    • Courses
      The School of Government
      offers up to 200 courses,
      workshops, webinars, and
      professional conferences
      each year.
      All Courses
      • Courses
      • Upcoming Courses
      • Online Modules
      • Webinar
      • Webinar Series
      • Continuing Professional Education
        Scholarship Opportunities
        Request a Transcript
      • Publications
        The School of Government
        publishes essential books,
        manuals, reports, articles,
        bulletins, and other print and
        online content related to state
        and local government.
        All Publications
        • Books
        • Book Chapters
        • Bulletins
        • Reports
        • Bulletin Series Index
          Publication Sales
        Browse
        • New Publications
        • Forthcoming Titles
        • Updates and Supplements
      • Blogs
        Faculty write for a number
        of School of Government
        blogs providing timely
        updates on emerging issues.
        • Coates' Canons: NC Local Government Law
        • Community and Economic Development
        • Death and Taxes
        • Environmental Finance
        • Facts That Matter
        • MPA Matters
        • North Carolina Criminal Law
        • On the Civil Side
        • Resources
          The School of Government
          offers information and
          services related to a wide
          range of topics relevant to
          government and judicial
          officials—in-person and on a
          variety of platforms.
          • Blog Posts
          • Timely updates on emerging issues
          • Centers and Services
          • Specialized training/research hubs and consulting services
          • Frequently Asked Questions
          • Aggregated answers to common questions on a variety of topics
          • Knapp Library
          • Print and online materials and research expertise
          • Legal Summaries
          • Brief descriptions of legal cases, bills, or legislative activity
          • Listservs
          • Information exchanges for peers and faculty experts
          • Microsites
          • In-depth or aggregated content for local government and judicial officials
          • Tools and Apps
          • Online and mobile tools for employees on-the-go
          • Master of Public
            Administration Program
            The UNC MPA program prepares public service leaders. The program is offered in two formats: on-campus and online.
            For more information, visit mpa.unc.edu
            MPA_Logo_Large_H_
              Why an MPA?
             
              Online or on-campus?
          • Giving
            The School of Government depends on private and public support for fulfilling its mission. Your gift will make a lasting impact on the quality of government and civic participation in North Carolina.
            • University Development
            • Make a Gift
            • Development FAQ
            • Knapp Library
              The Joseph Palmer Knapp Library houses a large collection of material on state and local government, public administration, and management to support the School's instructional and research programs and the educational mission of the Master of Public Administration program. Reference and research services are available to all residents of North Carolina, and additional assistance is available to state and local government personnel, both elected and appointed.
              • Covid-19 Response
              Resources | Legal Summaries

              Protest Petitions

              David W. Owens
              May, 2020
              Legal topic(s)
              Summary: 

              [Adapted from Owens, Land Use Law in North Carolina (4th ed., 2023)] 

              From 1923 through 2015, North Carolina zoning law provided that if a sufficient number of directly affected landowners formally objected to a zoning amendment, they could trigger a requirement that the amendment receive a three-fourths supermajority of the city council in order to be enacted. That provision was repealed in 2015.[1]

              While landowners and neighbors are significantly affected by zoning, the choice to change zoning restrictions is a discretionary policy choice of elected officials. Neither landowners nor neighbors can be given a veto over proposed zoning changes.[2] At the outset of local land use regulation, its proponents concluded that those most directly affected by zoning needed a degree of protection from unwanted changes in the land use policies they have relied on.[3] The provision for a protest petition was thus included in the state’s 1923 zoning-enabling act to provide a degree of certainty and stability in zoning while allowing the governing body sufficient flexibility to amend the ordinance to reflect changing needs and circumstances. Although infrequently used outside of large municipalities,[4] the protest petition proved controversial in application and its use was abolished in 2015.

              In lieu of the protest petition, the statute now provides that citizens can present written statements on proposed zoning amendments to the city clerk, who must then provide copies to the city council.[5]

               



              [1]. S.L. 2015-160. For a detailed review of the law on protest petitions when this statute was still in effect, see the 2011 edition of Land Use Law in North Carolina. David W. Owens, Land Use Law in North Carolina at 193-97 (2d ed., 2011).

              [2]. Early land use regulatory cases dealt with neighborhood vetoes with somewhat contradictory results, although the general rule quickly emerged that making the decision subject to neighbor approval was an unlawful delegation of legislative authority. See State of Washington ex rel. Seattle Title Trust Co. v. Roberge, 278 U.S. 116 (1928) (invalidating requirement of neighborhood approval for home for elderly poor); Eubank v. City of Richmond, 226 U.S. 137 (1912) (invalidating neighbor approval for setback line). But see Thomas Cusack Co. v. City of Chi., 242 U.S. 526 (1917) (allowing neighbors to waive sign restriction). For a contemporary example of incorporation of neighbor objections into a land use regulatory decision using the rationale of the Cusack Co. case, see Coffey v. County of Otoe, 274 Neb. 796, 743 N.W.2d 632 (2008). The court there upheld a county ordinance that prohibited the location of a residence within one-half mile of an animal feedlot unless the residential owner agreed to and recorded a “mutual impact easement” holding the feedlot owner harmless from odor, smoke, dust, or other impacts from the feedlot. The owner of a proposed residential lot challenged the provision as an unlawful delegation of governmental authority when an adjacent feedlot owner refused to enter into such an easement, thereby blocking construction of a residence on nearby property. The court distinguished between an ordinance allowing a neighbor to create the restriction (which would be invalid) from a provision allowing a neighbor to waive a lawfully created restriction.

              The North Carolina court has specifically held that neighbors have no right to the continuation of a particular zoning restriction. McKinney v. City of High Point, 239 N.C. 232, 237, 79 S.E.2d 730, 734 (1954).

              [3]. The protest petition was included in the nation’s first comprehensive zoning ordinance, New York’s 1916 ordinance. The legal architect of the New York ordinance noted that the provision for a protest petition was “a device for the protection of the property owner” and that its purpose was “to prevent easy or careless changes in the zoning regulations. . . . The 20 percent protest will often prevent impulsive or improper map changes.” Edward M. Bassett, Zoning 38 (1940).  

              [4]. In a 2006 School of Government survey, two-thirds of the responding cities reported that no protest petitions had been filed in the previous year. David W. Owens, Zoning Amendments in North Carolina 11 (UNC School of Government, Special Series No. 24, 2008). However, protests were much more common in those cities with large populations—50 percent of the cities with populations between 10,000 and 25,000 reported having received a protest petition, and 71 percent of the cities with populations over 25,000 had received one or more protest petitions in the previous year. Responding municipalities reported a total of 181 protest petitions filed in the previous year. Of these, 134 (75 percent) were determined to be adequate and thereby requiring a supermajority vote for adoption of the rezoning. These same municipalities reported consideration of 2167 rezoning petitions in the previous year. Thus only 8 percent of the municipal rezoning petitions had a protest filed, and only 6 percent had a protest sufficient to require a supermajority vote for the proposed rezoning to be enacted.

              [5]. G.S. 160D-603.

               

              Public Officials - Local and State Government Roles
              Attorneys
              Topics - Local and State Government
              Planning and Development Regulation

              Faculty Coordinators

              individual image for David W. Owens
              David W. Owens
              Gladys Hall Coates Professor of Public Law and Government
              owens@sog.unc.edu
              • About the School
              • Faculty and Staff
              • Events Calendar
              • Driving Directions
              • Knapp Library
              • Employment
              • Contact Us
              • Gladys
              • Employee Intranet
              • UNC Home Page
              • Employee Login
              • Information Technology
              • Registration Account Portal
              • Accessibility
              • UNC Privacy Policy
              Knapp-Sanders Building
              Campus Box 3330, UNC Chapel Hill
              Chapel Hill, NC 27599-3330
              • T: 919.966.5381
              • F: 919.962.0654
              © Copyright 2025,
              The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill